Company Car
Today

Your Independent source of fleet news, reviews & interviews

Analysis: Surge in RVs helps EVs make sense

Company Car Today - Green Company Car - The Green Pages Logo

The demand for new electric vehicles is growing with every month, and the residual value situation appears to be looking just as rosy

September was another record-breaking month for battery electric vehicles, with almost 22,000 registered to give the full electric technology a 6.7% share of the new car sales market and a 184.3% increase in registrations on September 2019. Last month accounted for almost a third of the total BEVs registered in what has been a rollercoaster 2020.

The year-to-date figure is just as positive, with full electric vehicle registrations 165.4% up on the first three-quarters of 2019, and accounting for 5.4% of all new car registrations, compared with just 1.3% for January-September last year.

But with incentives such as zero company car Benefit-in-Kind and company National Insurance cost for this tax year, and greatly reduced figures until at least April 2025, as well as the grant towards the purchase cost, all designed around at the first user, how are residual value experts expecting these cars to perform when they go to a second home?

In the very early days of electric vehicles at the beginning of the 2010s, it wasn’t unheard of for leasing companies to allocate a residual value of approaching zero to the few EVs available to early adopters, such was the concern about battery performance and the ability to find used buyers willing to adopt EVs. But the pace of change in new vehicle demand is, according to experts, being matched by the increased §knowledge, understanding and willingness to accept among used buyers.

“I don’t think there is a worry about the technology, there is a general acceptance of the technology across all makes, models and brands,” says Cap HPI’s senior values editor and EV expert, Chris Plumb.

“Over the past seven years I’ve been doing this, we’ve seen an improvement in used car demand for EVs and that will still be the case because there is a market for them, especially as new cars come in and hit certain price points. With the tech in the vehicles, over-the-air updates, eight-year battery warranties, there will be less risk to the used buyer and more confidence to take on the vehicle.”

“If I gave you an average position, then I would say electric vehicles are more at parity [with petrol and diesel], with a slight premium coming back,” says Paulo Larkman, head of fleet consultancy at Hitachi Capital Vehicle Solutions. “From a RV perspective we’re looking at a premium for electric cars over ICE.”

“In terms of the journey to there being a premium on EVs, that journey is not simply about the product, it’s not simply because EVs are now better or more desirable,” he continues. “The viability has increased and it’s been a gradual transition driven by a whole variety of things.”

 

CLIMATE AGENDA
One big advantage that electric vehicles have is the pace of change within society around climate objectives, including the high-profile low-emission zones coming to cities across the country.

“The clean air agenda will continue to grow and will drive demand,” says Cap’s Plumb, who also said increasing numbers of charge points will grow confidence.

“Another thing that’s going to improve the residual values of mainly electric but also a halo on hybrids is the optical availability of the charging infrastructure,” agrees Hitachi’s Larkman. “As people drive through the likes of Tesco and Asda, the visible infrastructure will make the product more desirable.”

Plumb adds:“I’m confident that there is a private retail market, the good sales from the private sector of the new market show that there is interest.

“Mainstream vehicles will see more stability in values as demand increases but more expensive ones will be under a bit more pressure. Petrol, diesel, electric, plug-in hybrid, hybrid, mild hybrid – it’s all supply and demand, and EVs are not immune to that.

“I would hope that the market will be ready for the increase in used EVs in three years; manufacturers have produced really good used car remarketing programmes – a used car PCP opens up a bigger market,” he continues. “And more independent specialists are growing that are very good at selling vehicles.”

Understanding of the technology will also boost demand, according to car retailing group Robins & Day’s chief executive, James Weston.

“The noise and awareness is starting to increase, and it drips on to more people’s potential purchase lists, and that then filters down into the used market” he tells Company Car Today. “I very much don’t see EVs sitting on used forecourts for long.

“One thing for sure is that enquiry levels will continue to grow, and as more products come from more manufacturers, the noise generates enquiries.”

 

LONGER RUNS
Customers, both fleet and retail are also potentially going to run electric vehicles for longer to help off-set the up-front investment, which will mitigate the quantity of supply coming through of any one age or mileage, as the industry is used to with petrol or diesel vehicles at a typical three- or four-year cycle.

“As a buying model of running the car for longer, it becomes more profitable; there’s no reason we won’t see that,” continues Chris Plumb of Cap HPI. “It’s an exciting time for EVs and they’re not going away.”

Paul Barker

 

EV RVS VS ICE


Electric residual values have now reached a point where they are generally comparable with petrol- or diesel-engined models.

As is the case with regular models, plug-in cars now seem to be subject to the same variables as petrol or diesel in terms of different models performing better or worse according to factors such as volumes, desirability and how the manufacturer behaves in relation to discounting and approaches to different market channels.

This table uses Kee Resources data to look at the residual value and whole-life cost of different powertrains available in the same or similar models, as well as the comparable company National Insurance over the next three years and monthly company car Benefit-in-Kind cost to a 40% taxpayer this tax year.

 

Powertrain         P11D Price       Depreciation         Whole          National          BiK

(no grant)           (%/cost)            Life Cost       Insurance

 

Peugeot 208 Allure

Electric                       £30,170           37.2  £18,945            50.6p                £125                £0

Diesel                          £21,025           34.8  £13,700            48.6p               £2176          £168

Petrol                          £19,525           39.3  £12,225            47.8p               £2344          £182

Mini Cooper S

Electric                       £27,845           43.1  £15,848            45.2p                £115                £0

Petrol                          £20,860           40.9  £12,335            53.9p               £2850          £223

Hyundai Ioniq Premium SE

Electric                       £35,895           35.7  £23,070            56.5p                £149                £0

PHEV                           £32,195           38.4  £19,845            52.2p               £1466          £107

Hybrid                         £27,840           41.4  £16,315            54.5p               £2881          £223

Kia Niro 3

Electric                       £36,795           40.8  £21,795            56.0p                £152                £0

PHEV                           £31,890           41.7  £18,590            50.9p               £1452          £106

Petrol                          £26,880           46.2  £14,455            52.7p               £3005          £233

MG ZS Excite

Electric                       £28,440           35.8  £18,265            49.4p                £118                £0

Petrol                          £17,400           35.8  £11,175            49.6p               £2641          £209

Mercedes-Benz EQC/GLC AMG Line

Electric                       £67,600           54.9  £30,535            86.0p                £280                £0

PHEV                           £49,617           40.4  £29,592            86.8p               £3081          £232

Diesel       £43,075    40.1  £25,475            96.9p        £6598       £531

 

PHEV PHILOSOPHY

The situation around residual values isn’t quite so clear for plug-in hybrids, with a question mark over the future value of a technology seen as a stop-gap by some on the route to full electric.

“PHEVs have been an interesting one to monitor over the past couple of years,” says Cap HPI’s Chris Plumb. “The BiK rates mean PHEVs will continue to grow in new car registrations, and some manufacturers may use PHEVs as a way to move away from diesel, because there’s no range anxiety and the MPG can be comparable to that of diesel, but the growth hasn’t translated to used, because where is the benefit to the used buyer?”

“They’re more expensive than ICE, they need to get to a certain price point to be attractive, so they have been under pressure and have stabilised after a turbulent start,” he continues. According to Cap HPI, PHEVs are at a year-on-year price deflation of around 4%, while petrol is up 9% and diesel up 6%.

“The number of PHEVs out there – three times the number of EVs – means it’s a more mature market,” says Paulo Larkman of Hitachi Capital Vehicle Solutions. “There is a lot more knowledge of what is going back into the used market, and the fact that the premium is declining suggests the position three years ago was optimistic and there is a market concern, and I think that will continue.”

Car manufacturers also admit that PHEVs may have enjoyed too positive an early position. “At the moment there are obvious RV increases on electric and declining slightly on PHEV, which is possibly due to the market reacting to a very strong initial position,” Peugeot’s UK managing director, David Peel, tells Company Car Today. “We’ve had a move to strengthen RVs on 208 and 2008 since we launched [early this year]. PHEV is a little more of a challenge, we’ve seen Cap forecast a decrease in RVs as a general market position.”

“We’ve managed PHEV carefully, we are seeing demand for PHEV, there are benefits of going PHEV for certain users, there is a marketplace and customer for it.”

paul barker